Kimler Sidebar Menu

Kimler Adventure Pages: Journal Entries

search cloudRandom Searches
random top 40

Weather Forecast for Yellow Point, B.C.

Today

N/A

N/A

N/A° C

POP - 10%

Tonight

Mostly Clear

Mostly Clear

15° C

POP - 10%

Tomorrow

Mostly Sunny

Mostly Sunny

23° C 13° C

POP - 10%

Thu 10-Jul

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

21° C 13° C

POP - 20%

Fri 11-Jul

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

22° C 14° C

POP - 20%

Sat 12-Jul

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

22° C 14° C

POP - 10%

Weather data provided by weather.com®

Tricky Tranny Troubles

Tricky Tranny Troubles

March 18th, 2006  · stk

We'll never purchase a Chrysler automobile again and we're recommending you don't either. Read about our experience with a poorly engineered mini-van transmission and ridiculous experience with the Chrysler Customer Service. The transmission failed three hours from home, cost us $2,500 US to repair and customer service has been absolutely NO help whatsoever...

chrysler thumbs down

I'll never buy another Chrysler automobile and I'm recommending that you don't either. The transmission problems we had on our mini-van were astonishing and costly, but it's their lousy customer service that solidifies my position.

Troublesome Transmission

We bought a used 1993 Plymouth Grand Voyager LE. It was 10 years old and had 118,000 kilometers (approximately 73,000 miles) on the odometer. It was in supurb condition, both physically and mechanically. It was the largest version of the model year, had AWD, a large 3.3 liter engine, a towing package, electric controls & leather seats. We paid $4,500 CAD for it and thought it was a good value, considering its features and condition.

We drove it locally, for a month, then took it on a 1,200-mile family vacation, to see Scott's folks, in California. The transmission acted funny on the way down, refusing to go into gear immediately at a stop sign and shifting jerkily on a couple of occasions. In California, we drained the transmission fluid, replaced the transmission filter and refilled it with the recommended "Mopar 7176" fluid.

On the return trip, we stopped to visit with friends in Seattle, spending the night. Upon our departure, the transmission refused to deliver power, leaving us stranded in Seattle. We opted for a genuine Mopar replacement transmission, which came with a 3-year/36,000-mile warranty. The bill totalled $3,503.89, plus incidental expenses, including a bus ride, back to Vancouver. It was an frustrating experience and and expensive repair.

That a transmission would fail at 73,000 miles is unbelievable. The mechanic who replaced the tranny said, "These transmissions are known to be troublesome and only last for about that [70,000 miles]. My advice? Drive the vehicle for another 70,000 miles and then sell it, before it needs another transmission."

Some stuff on a car needs to be replaced, including oil, tires, brake pads, a water pump (perhaps) and the odd fan belt. But not transmissions! Certainly not at $2,700.00 USD a pop and certainly not three or four times, over the life of a vehicle. Shame on Chrysler for such shoddy engineering.

But, that's not the end of the story and it's their customer service that really made me part ways with DaimlerChrysler. To learn about the customer service fiasco, read on ...

- -

Worrisome Warranty & Poor Customer Support

Canada and the United States are friendly neighbors. They share similar values, operate under a free trade agreement and many of the businesses that operate south of the border, operate north of the border. But, they're two different countries and the companies in each, are independently operated. There's Chrysler U.S.A. and Chrysler Canada. We worried that our U.S. Mopar warranty might not be honored in Canada (especially since the Canadian warranty had slightly different terms).

We asked various dealerships, both in Canada and the U.S., if there was a reciprocal agreement for honoring warranties. As you can imagine, it's not a question that comes up much and we received a disparity of replies. So, I called Chrysler Canada, hoping for a definitive answer, which I was relieved to receive. "Yes, warranties are honored throughout North America," said Stephanie, the Customer Service representative. Although a relief, a verbal response doesn't do much good when faced with a dealership that says, "No, we can only honor Canadian warranties."

My feeble retort would likely not garner much support, "But when I spoke with your Customer Service representative, Stephanie, on the phone, she said it would be honored."

When I conveyed the desire for written confirmation, Stephanie provide the file number for our telephone call and an address to which I could write, requesting a transcript of the call. So I wrote, thinking it would put the matter to rest, our minds eased that if needed to exercise the warranty, we'd be covered. Imagine my dismay when I received the following reply from a Chrylser Canada Customer Service Manager (S. Mailloux):

We have received your letter ... which is further to your previous contact with our Customer Assistance Center regarding your 1993 Plymouth Grand Voyager.

Please note that DaimlerChrysler Canada remains available to review the possibility of warranty coverage (my emphasis) for future repair required to your vehicle's transmission with the receipt of all pertinent required documentation.

What? 88| This isn't the confirmation I was requesting or expecting. What kind of corporate CYA mumbo jumbo is this? I was appalled and couldn't believe my eyes.

I wrote back, indicating that I was "disappointed with their reply" and that it certainly wasn't confirmation of their commitment to honor a U.S. warranties in Canada. "The question is simple: 'Will Chrysler Canada honor a genuine Mopar Warranty for a genuine Mopar part, installed in the U.S. - Yes or No?' "

The second response, from a different Customer Service Manager (R. Ramos) didn't nothing to reassure me of Chrysler's commitment to their product, warranties or customers. It only cemented my belief that their customer service department steadfastly refused to answer to a straightforward question.

We regret any misunderstanding regarding the position taken by DaimlerChrysler Canada with regard to your prior concerns. Based on our assessment of your file, it was concluded that the appropriate information had been provided in our earlier reply. Our primary objective is the satisfaction of our customers; however, pursuing this goal may not always include the full relief expected in a particular situation.

All I really wanted was, "Yes, provided that all the paperwork is in order, warranties are honored throughout North America". Why is that so difficult? There was the telephone call log, if they had printed a transcript of the call, I'd have been satisfied. We are really hoping the transmission doesn't fail again, or that we'll need any warranty work, especially anticipating the battle at the dealership just trying to get our valid warranty honored.

Because of a poorly engineered transmission, we were stranded in Seattle and incurred $3,500 CAD out-of-pocket expenense for a Mopar replacement. That's bad enough, but it's the ridiculous manner in which Chrysler responded to our warranty question that is driving me to part ways with Chrysler. Though they couldn't commit to providing us with an answer to our straightforward question, I CAN commit to letting others know about our experience. I CAN commit to the avoidance of Chrysler products, forever more. And I can commit to recommending, vigorously that others do the same.

(Permalink)
Views: 12688 views
8 Comments · Email Story
Updated: 24-Sep-2007
Web View Count: 12688 viewsLast Web Update: 24-Sep-2007

Your Two Sense:

XHTML tags allowed. URLs & such will be converted to links.


Subscribe to Comments

Auto convert line breaks to <br />

1.flag Dad Comment
04/02/06
Why don't you email this story to President, Chrysler Canada and explain it is posted on the web. Don't say where. Let him search if interested. You might get some satisfaction.(?)
2.flag Wammara Comment
08/24/07
Our tranny has failed us on our 2001 Caravan while we were vacationing too. We are waiting to hear what the cost will be but it has turned me off chrysler too after we have been long time customers.

3.flag stk Comment
08/24/07
Wammara,

Sorry to hear about your transmission woes. I know EXACTLY how you feel.

We still have our minivan, but are eager to sell it (we will be selling it, this autumn). We'll NEVER buy or recommend a Chrysler product and it sounds like you won't either.

Spread the word.

Cheers,
-stk
4.flag TB Comment
09/24/07
Youre an idiot. I sell these vans and one bad experience doesnt justify your claim to never buy another Chrysler. We have never had a problem like the one you are describing. Im so sick and tired of people saying the foreign marques are so much better (not that you said that here, but Im sure you would agree with it). They are not any better or worse. Chryslers are just as reliable as a Honda, Nissan and Toyota (I sell these too), and Im sure if you researched it, similar numbers would be found for all makes / models of minivans.
5.flag stk Comment
09/24/07
ROLFL TB!! Lemme see ... I have a Master's Degree in Geophysics from PSU, I invented "Photo-Caption Zoom", I don't name-call and utilize decent grammar. Yep, I'm an idiot alright! rolleyes

Firstly, it's Chrysler's poor customer service that sealed the deal for me, not the transmission. Secondly, I'm not alone with my Chrysler transmission woes. Thirdly, it's unreasonable that anyone should purchase a bunch of Chrysler mini-vans, to see if they all fail in similar fashion, before coming to a conclusion.

A reasonable person would buy one and if it fails, be leery about purchasing another. There are enough GOOD automobile manufacturers that no one needs to waste their money & time on a loser.

Sure, I'm not happy about the transmission failing and why should I be? Consumers shouldn't have to expect to replace their transmission every 70,000 miles!

You say that "Chryslers are just as reliable as a Honda, Nissan and Toyota". Nope! My 1983 Honda Accord has NEVER needed a transmission and its got 178,000 miles on it.

Which is the better experience is obvious, even to this idiot!

I stand by what I say.

-stk
6.flag Mech Comment
11/24/07
well here's a little tidbit for everyone..

i own a 1990 grand voyager,has 286000 klm,yes 286000.i've owned this van for many a year.get this trick,,regular annual service..hint hint.i know vehicles in general can be a pain at times,i'm not defending or damning any Vehicle,i drop my trans fluid and filter every six months no matter the mileage.the 4 speed auto trans in the caravan or the voyager had an issue with burning out the over drive clutch thusly breaking the retainer snap ring for the clutch pack.why??? because we change our engine oil and never think of the tranny.

yes when I first bought my van it had this very problem,it had 146000k,and no overdrive and would screw up upon shifting.the trans cost me 1700.00 cdn to replace.now at 286000 i have never had an issue with it, service your transmission,it will save you in the long run, wondering how i know this??? i'm a certified automotive technician,i see this every day.

and to be fair yes the trans is poorly designed and prone to failure,allot of the rebuilders have an upgrade for this problem
i'm told,we'll see.

yours truly: kw
7.flag DPBG Comment
12/15/07
I hae a 1996 plmputh voyager. WHAT A PIECE OF GARBAGE. The trans went 3 times and it has just failed again. What a piece of garbage. After the second one we started servicing it every x km but it does not help. Nothng mmakes a piece of garbage better. We origionally paid 14000 for the van and put well over that into repairs. Close to 20000. If you want to own a piece of crap and have 20000 dollars for reapirs go ahead and get 1.
8.flag stk Comment
12/17/07
Mech - Yes, I've heard that about regular service (and special Mopar 7176 fluid).

What other transmissions require such "babying"? Even with such superfluous care, there's lots of folks that STILL have Chrysler transmission failures. ;)

DPBG - I feel your pain.

An update on our van: The genuine Mopar tranny for which we paid $4,500 CAD, failed two months ago, at about 20,000 miles. Because it was past the 3-year warranty (by 4 months), Chrysler couldn't run away fast enough. Twenty thousand miles and then failure! Ridiculous!!

We disposed of our "piece of garbage" mini-van, which had less than 150,000 kilometers on it, ran great, was in EXCELLENT condition ... for a mind-numbing price of $450 CAD.

I hope to do a full-blown post-mortem on this Chrysler debacle, because IMO, the car was the worst I've ever owned and I hope to keep others from buying vehicles from such an awful company.

We paid a huge price, but now we're "Chrysler free" (and will be, till the day we die).

Let's all do the Mopar Chant: "Don't buy Chrysler, don't buy Chrysler ... Stay Away, Stay Away!"